Ventilation approaches, compared

Open windows, range hood, HRV/ERV, demand-controlled ventilation. Different ways to bring fresh air in and stale air out.

Also in: Français Español

Diagram showing four ventilation paths: open window, range hood vent, HRV unit, and an HVAC damper.
Photo: Daniel Frese via Pexels

Bringing outdoor air indoors is how you dilute everything: CO2 from breathing, VOCs from materials, humidity from showering, residual particulates from cooking. The four common approaches make different tradeoffs between energy efficiency, control, and source-targeting.

Natural ventilation (open windows, trickle vents): free, no equipment, no energy penalty for the air exchange itself. Cost: zero control over rate or quality. Open a window on an ozone-high or pollen-high day and you import the problem. Best as a supplement when outdoor conditions are favorable; see open vs closed windows.

Range hoods are source-specific local exhaust ventilation: they remove cooking emissions at the source, before they distribute through the home. The single highest-leverage ventilation upgrade for households that cook with gas. Limitation: only addresses the kitchen, only while it is running, and only if the hood actually vents outdoors rather than recirculating. Range hood details.

Heat or Energy Recovery Ventilators (HRV/ERV) are balanced mechanical ventilation: they push stale air out and pull fresh air in through a heat exchanger, recovering 70 to 90% of the temperature differential. The standard answer in tight new homes and in cold climates where opening windows in winter is a losing proposition. Demand-controlled ventilation (commercial) dynamically adjusts outdoor-air intake based on actual occupancy via CO2 sensors. DCV details. For most residential users, the practical answer is: range hood for cooking, natural for nice days, HRV/ERV for everything else if you have one.

References

  1. ASHRAE Standard 62.1 - Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality www.ashrae.org
  2. ASHRAE Standard 62.2 - Residential ventilation www.ashrae.org
  3. LBNL - Demand-controlled ventilation review doi.org
  4. LBNL - Kitchen range-hood effectiveness doi.org